I always imagined Ian Somerhalder as Ian!

For a long time I imagined Jared Padalecki ( sweet dark blue eyes)
as Ian but later I thought Matt Dallas is a better match. Very nice photo of Matt you added here.
Now I like Henry more.

Yep, he looks like Ian. But I'm close to new ideas about Ian. :Sorry
I cant think anyone else.

Ian Somerhalder looks like Ian O'Shea.

I also like Sean Faris, he would be a good Ian, he's my second choice.

It was Kellan for me the entire time I was reading

Ian will always be my best Ian.

Definitely. He would be the perfect Ian.

i can't imagine anyone now, i have my own Ian and definitely Kellan Lutz is on bottom of my list.....:)

i think cam will be fantastic as ian hes so sexy and he looks alot like kellan lutz who i picked for kyle, when i read the book i see cam as ian, these 2 have the waw factor for me, and should be the o,shea brothers,

Since the first time I saw Tom Welling as Ian, he fits perfectly on the description.
Ian Somerhalder is awesome, but he is too small, he's 5.9, when Ian O'Shea sould have around 6.2 (I don't know if the measures are right, here in Brazil is a bit different. Sorry).

Erik Fellows is an up and comer who needs to be seen!! I watched him on Day's of our lives as "TROY" and fell in love with him... I think he would be perfect for Ian and i hope people will check him out and vote:

link

I'm also familiar with Erik from Days..... great looking man not unlike the other contestants but also a great actor and in my opinion would be perfect for Ian. If your not sure who to vote for ~ pick Erik! :)

PICK ERIK FELLOWS! they need an fresh face. plus he's gorgeous. ;)

I remember Erik from Days too. I haven't really seen him anywhere else. Out of all of the guys, he has not done much but he made an impact. I think he needs a chance. Plus hes nice to look at.

Why is Erik the only one without a professional photo? Clearly we all know he is better looking then that.
link

picked Erik Fellows - Erik can bring it .....he is gorgeous - he is a great actor - he is just very very very good at whatever scene e does....you have got to follow Erik he will be the next big thing.....He should of been already !!!!

i just picked chase crawford cuz he's hot!

Watched Erik on DOOL.. love him!!!

Vote for Ian Somerhalder

VOTE FOR IAN SOMERHALDER

Vote for Ian Somerhalder

Vote for Erik, he so sexy

Ian is the best vote for him

ERIK FELLOWS...freaking hot

VOTE FOR IAN SOMERHALDER ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

VOTE FOR IAN SOMERHALDER

VOTE FOR IAN SOMERHALDER

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ ian ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

Mr. Fellows

ian the best

I couldn't get to watch Erik Fellows in anything but in the photos I saw, he looks like a bad boy to me but I must say he's a really good-looking guy :)

Erik seems to be a good choice too, but isn't he too old? S:

Actually Erik is one of the younger ones up here!! Tom welling is like 4 yrs older than Erik Fellows

Ian is supposed to be 25. Stephenie Meyer said in an interview that Ian is 25 and Kyle is 30. Here's the source link

Yeah, Tom is older than Erik, but he can seem like a 25 year old guy easily. And I just said it because I saw Erik just on pictures, not on the screen.

I read someone Erik is going to be doing a movie called "The List" and he is playing 19yrs old... he looks pretty young in this pic i think he can range from 19 to 28 if he has to.. he is very versatile...check it out

link

Watch some of Erik's video on youtube... so freaking HOT

It's funny that they even put Rob on this list,I mean I adore him,but he is so not how I see Ian O'Shea,lol Anyways my vote goes to Ian Somerhalder

I put him there. But I agree with you. He does not fit. Just I saw a few people that wants him to play Ian :/

I realize that Andy Whitfield has lovely blue eyes but if you make him Ian, you're gonna have to find a much older Kyle, you know. I thought of him more like a Kyle.

Erik Fellows is the Man.... If not Ian than should be cast as Kyle

ERIK

I voted Erik!!

Ian Somerhalder all the way!!! Actually I think he's been confirmed for the role, some places say rumored though usually that indicates the actor is possibly already attached to the project!!!! Can't wait, love him!!!1<3

Erik Fellows

ian somerhalder is the official Ian O'Shea yayyy!!!! u can check it on wikkipedia

Erik Fellows all the way

Ian Somerhalder is Erik's evil looking twin.

Totally Ian! No one else can pull of harsh but sweet.

Definitely Ian

In my mind Jared Padalecki should be Ian And Jensen Ackles should be Jared!!! *too much Supernatural lol*

Jake Gyllenhal (can wear contacts), but his look in Prince of Persia is "weathered" as if he's been stranded in the desert. Plus, his has that "longing" look that I truly believe Ian has, esp at end, when being tormented news of Wanda's choice. I think I would "feel" that pain.

Ian <3 <3 <3

Erik Fellows is great loved him on DOOL

Ian Somerhalder is very similar to Ian O'shea to me:) It would be cool for him to portray Ian in the movie! I have my fingers crossed for it to happen.

Seriously (: I just see it.

Jensen Ackles too

Looks like Erik Fellows link. is rumored to be in "The Host" as Ian!! Awesome

Erik is rumored to be playing Ian hope its true

only Ian

of course Ian;)

Erik is rumored to be playing Ian O'shea...thats awesome

Mr. Fellows all the way...He was great on Day's

Erik wins my vote

Erik Fellows... Hot

Who voted for Erik Fellows! He can not be Ian! I mean honestly when you read the book did you picture him as Ian? Don't think so!
I mean Sean Farris is way better an Ian than him!

Actually I can see Erik as Ian and obviously so do lot of others clearly and Sean Faris looks like a rat!!

like the idea of Erik playing Ian... He is Hot

I always imagined Ian Somerhalder as Ian!!!!!!

Henry Cavill would be the best.

Maybe Ian... i can not pick one, but i like J.A as Jared!