I don't disagree. But this is my dream cast link

Though I'd update it and say that link would be perfect.

She's a great actress but she just looks too innocent looking and looks more like a Disney Princess than she does a villainess. Plus, her being short kind of makes her come off as less intimidating. Not to mention that her voice would make her sound more like a Regina George type rather than the cold and tough Icy we know and love.

That's kind of what I was thinking; she's got a very soft face.

Though I disagree on the short thing. As a short person myself, we can be intimidating. Azula is smol and she hella intimidating. Granted I've always headcanoned Icy to be super tall.

True, short people can be intimidating but it's a different type of intimidation and one that I don't think would work for Icy, who I've always seen as a statuesque woman that towered over others with her strong presence. As for Azula, I think her height has to do with her being only 14, even though she looks 18.

She looks too soft and non intimidating which would hard to take her seriously as Icy even with dark makeup.