ok so what do you all think of this no soul thing with Sam? not sure if its really working for the show or not.

i love him anyway

Weeeeeeelllllll, it a good story but a little annoying, want normal sam back!!!

Could someone please explain to me how you can know what's right and what's wrong w/out a soul, when it's your soul that tells you right from wrong???

In answer to your question, this is probably my second-least favorite season so far. Just because they're not really brothers. For the first time in six years, they're not brothers. Just that thought alone is enough to make me cry.

This "missing his soul" storyline is interesting, no doubt...but, it's time for Sam to get his soul back, already. I don't want the "real" Sam back for just the very last episode or so. Miss my "Good to a fault" Sammy.

I miss good Sam... Really, really bad. But there has to be something to keep the story going. He couldn't just come back and be okay, if that happened the season would end in two episodes.
As for if he still knows right from wrong, no, I don't think he can. I totally agree with shomill at this. He needs his emotions to guide him.

well its keeping you into the show - will he get his soul back - will their be more seasons - or do think its funny the Sams being really mean - or do you just miss old Sammy - but Sams changed so much over the last 5 years - if he ever comes back from hell how will be ?