Which 2006 movie about magicians is better?? Poll Results - Movies

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Movies Which 2006 movie about magicians is better??

1367 fans picked:

The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel

55%

The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc

45%

spiderweb12 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

70 comments

	ktlady picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I saw both and liked both. Both had awesome twists... but I just didn't find the romance in The Illusionist to be believable. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	roundabouts picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: they were both ok films, but i just think Bale is ace. this film was more gritty for me which i like. although Giamatti is sooo cool posted over a year ago.

	bluegeorgia picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: by far the prestige! it was an experienced i've never felt before in the movies... u never saw that endig coming...really brilliant...actors,script,scenery... i would agree with one critic ''the minute it finishes,you want to watch it again...'' and with roundabouts... Christian bale IS ace....one of my favs... i wasnt so impressed with the illusionist posted over a year ago.

	Mindfreak666 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: The Prestige = Awesome!! posted over a year ago.

	PamHalpert454 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: I just like Edward Norton as an actor which makes it maximizes how much I actually like it, I recently saw the prestige and enjoyed it as well. posted over a year ago.

	tubby2002 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: Awsome movie! posted over a year ago.

	FindingxDisco picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I can't stand Paul Giamantti...and also, the Illusionist was way to predictable. Why would that horse still be riding away in the right direction if she were dead? Seriously posted over a year ago.

	iLuVBETTy picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: the prestige in all honesty was pretty close to terrible. the smarter it tried ti get the dumber it got. the illusionist was a cinematic acheivment. it was not predictable and interesting the whole way. where they prestige was good for five minutes. posted over a year ago.

	katie89 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: actually i've never see the prestige but i LOVE LOVE LOVE the illusionist! edward norton = hot posted over a year ago.

	pinkmad17 said: I won't vote as i've never seen The Prestige but The Illusionist was great! posted over a year ago.

	officefan2010 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: this movie was freaking amazing!!!! its one of my favortist movies ever! posted over a year ago.

	DarthVibbert picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: like both of them alot, but liked the prestige much more posted over a year ago.

	Kitzo picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: The Prestige was just awful. The Illusionist had dramatic flare and a thrilling plot. No contest. posted over a year ago.

	Safgra picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: You guys all have good personal points about why you chose the one you did...but simply...its Tyler Durden's other half V's Batman & Wolverine...nuff said posted over a year ago.

	nosemuffin picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: They were both good, but with the Illusionist, I saw the end coming. The Prestige was too strange to be predictable. posted over a year ago.

	lupisuzz picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: WOW...they were both great in their own right! Prestige definately tricked me in the end... posted over a year ago.

	Jillywinkles picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: Everyone kept telling me how great the Prestige was, but when I finally saw it, I wasn't impressed. It felt way too long, the whole plot was convoluted, and the "twist" at the end was not believable. posted over a year ago.

	Mizrahi_sWifey picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: They were both great movies but the Illusionist kept you guessing and there were more suspense moments. I like Hugh Jackman and Ed Norton equally well... hard to choose. Gotta give Michael Caine a hand though, he had a great part. posted over a year ago.

	blind_moon picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I loove both stories! I love the actors, they had one of the best performances! The both had a loot of questioning! They are both on my top... But Prestige had a more surprise ending, I was kind of guessing the end of the illusionist, the prestige just took me of surprise! Great Films anyway! posted over a year ago.

	imprint-on-me picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I liked the Illusionist, but I think Prestige was better. It was just more unpredictable posted over a year ago.

	walker93 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: the prestige gave me the creeps posted over a year ago.

	wildcats13 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: They were both incredibly awsome!!! I loved the romance in "The Illusionist" and then ending was marvelous! I guess I'm just dumb, but b/c I totally did not see it coming. The music was amazing 2! I think "The Prestige" had a lot more story to it, and though it was harder to follow, it was a better movie all around. posted over a year ago.

	atari picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: I didn't like the Prestige at all. It has all the elements I would normally like in a movie, length, intelligence, twists, Christian Bale...but the Illusionist was much more interesting to me, and I really liked how they set it all up. posted over a year ago.

	tnme picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: I found the Prestige long, boring, and hard to understand The illusionist was so original and I didn't truly know what was going to happen, like in a lot of movies nowadays posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	michellekim116 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: FREAKING GOOD!! THE ILLUSIONIST WAS SO COOL! posted over a year ago.

	irishpapelbon58 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: Edward Norton is an amazing actor & incredibly beautiful, & he shines in this film. He makes everything so believable & the love story is so sweet (especially the locket). He's such an acting chamelion. It's amazing to watch him preform. The ending was such a shocker & i love films that can pull my feet out from under me like that. posted over a year ago.

	Krazi-K picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: well... i havent seen either i just know that hugh jackman is a good actor and i dont even think i spelled his last name right posted over a year ago.

	momo_228 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: this was really hard and i love the prestige too posted over a year ago.

	music_is_love27 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: the prestige was such an interesting movie, it had awesome plot and was a really interesting look at how far people will go and what they're willing to do. but i thought the ending was kind of silly, i mean hugh jackman had a cloning machine. thats kind of ridiculous... and the illusionist was just so cute and i thought the plot was a lot better put together. also i'm a sucker for romances from childhood :P posted over a year ago.

	dottyjay picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: i love the turn of the century look to the illusionist. ed norton was believable. a lot of surprises and illusions. very entertaining. i would see it again. posted over a year ago.

	neillylad picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: i havent seen any of the movies i just picked the one that sounds the best posted over a year ago.

	jennyrules1504 said: Can't pick posted over a year ago.

	ladycroft picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: course the prestige, the illusionist is soo predictable posted over a year ago.

	2va picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: i can't stop watching it! one of the movies that surprise me everytime i watch them! posted over a year ago.

	ChiliFan101 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: both movies were awesome but I enjoyed the Illusionist little bit more posted over a year ago.

	tinkymel picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: I enjoyed both movies about the same. I love norton and bale. I think the loves story in illusionist go me though. Hey I'm a girl sometimes. hehe. posted over a year ago.

	ClonedPickle said: Never watched any of 'em. O_o posted over a year ago.

	Hilary_Bells picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: i like both, but i think the illusionist is better posted over a year ago.

	NCISGIBBS picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Never seen either so i just chose at random! posted over a year ago.

	akzmustang picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: i saw illusionist,i really liked d movie,itz totally awsum posted over a year ago.

	Jaws75 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I really haven't seen either of these movies... I've seen the trailer for the The Prestige and it looked good, so I'm going with that one posted over a year ago.

	Lolaa picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: They are both really good movies. The actors are amazing. I think I liked The Prestige a bit more, the ending was very surprising. posted over a year ago.

	gaeliclassy picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: The two movies were done very well and the tricks were state of the art, but I choose The Illusionist because I was more entertained in a good way than The Prestige, don't get me wrong I liked it, but it was too dark despite having David Bowie in it! posted over a year ago.

	MadamOcta13 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Only because my parents saw this one. posted over a year ago.

	pink_martini2 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: Both were kinda meh in my opinion. But I didn't like the ending in the prestige. posted over a year ago.

	Shinshika picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: The "twist" in The Illusionist was really dumb. And Jessica Biel has zero acting talent so she detracted from how awesome Edward Norton is. posted over a year ago.

	McDreamyluva picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Great movie! and also because Hugh Jackman was in it =D posted over a year ago.

	tribro picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: the prestige is better but i found the ending 2 predictable posted over a year ago.

	lydianm picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Haven't seen either, but The Prestige has Hugh Jackman in it... Enough said! posted over a year ago.

	VintageSmile picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: Only because of Edward. I really don't like Biel as an actress and yes, the romance was slightly unbeliavble because of her :[ posted over a year ago.

	AthenaK picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: They were both exceptional movies, I liked them both. But the Prestige had Christain Bale and Hugh Jackman AND DAVID BOWIE AS NICOLA TESLA!!! YOu can't beat that!! posted over a year ago.

	yermam picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Such a hard decision!! posted over a year ago.

	tribro3 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: One of the best movies ive ever seen posted over a year ago.

	CuteDiana picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: By FAR posted over a year ago.

	ecpjll picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: never seen either...but anything with Ed Norton is good...so chances are i'd prefer that 1. posted over a year ago.

	wolverinerokkz picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Go Hugh Jackman!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i <3 u!!!! posted over a year ago.

	chattycatty picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: never herd any of em remember im from italy so they dont show lots of non italian movies posted over a year ago.

	Antelo picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I liked both films, but "The Prestige" is much better! posted over a year ago.

	XvxBERSERKxvX picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: David Bowie, that is all.... posted over a year ago.

	HouseAddict87 picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I just thought it was the better of the two, which were both good movies. posted over a year ago.

	KissOfDoom picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: I loved how dark the Prestige was, and I found it trully original. I honestly didn't enjoy the romance thing in The Illusionist :/ posted over a year ago.

	ManicMind picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Both were good though. posted over a year ago.

	iMimsicles picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: this movie blew me away! posted over a year ago.

	bene22 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: I love both :( posted over a year ago.

	Whiff picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: more interesting besides i don't like Jessica Bill.. posted over a year ago.

	frankthe2nd picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: The Illusionist was boring and predictable. posted over a year ago.

	Ann_happy_ picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: oh, i think The Illusionist is very good movie. really recomend:) posted over a year ago.

	csiAthens96 picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: i love both but i choose the illusionist because i adore edward norton posted over a year ago.

	slurp picked The Illusionist - starring Ed Norton and Jessica Biel: well... posted over a year ago.

	fanfly picked The Prestige - starring Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman etc: Love this movie. The Illusionist was just blah. posted over a year ago.

Add Your Comment

Movies

Movies Which 2006 movie about magicians is better??

70 comments

Sign In or join Fanpop to add your comment

Movies more polls