answer this question

Harry Potter Question

I have a question...

In the prisoner of azkaban, dumbledore says that the dementors can't be fooled by invisibilty cloaks whilst looking knowingly at Harry - but if the cloak was created to hide people even from Death then surely it should work on the dementors too?
 saz19126 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

bri-marie said:
Possibly. We don't know much about dementors -- do they even have eyes? They thrive on misery, a feeling -- do they "find" people by sensing their feelings? Moody's magical eye could see through it. Is it possible that magic can be used to see through it? Was the story a literal "Death himself made the cloak" or was it a aesop fable, a metaphor, a similie, or just a story?

Also: did Dumbles know the cloak was a Hallow at the time? We know he suspected it, but did he know?

There's way to many unknown variables to be able to truly say.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Not sure whether Dumbledore knew about it - but Death did make the cloak and you're probably right about the dementors sensing people rather than seeing since they don't have eyes but Moody's eye now has me stumped instead lol
saz19126 posted over a year ago
dracofan001 said:
yes but i really don't think that they can SEE you. i think they can sense your presence because i don't think they have eyes.They aint got no eyes. O.O
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
youre right! My friend jsut confirmed it, GoF chapter 35, "dementors are blind"
Unspeakable posted over a year ago
Unspeakable said:
Dementors live off human happiness, they are such good guards of Azkaban because they can sense humans, they don't have to "see" them. Happiness to them is live bacon to men, a guy could find a plate of bacon with his eyes closed. Death wants to take the physical person(in the world of harry potter Death seems to be entirely physical), Dementors would take the soul, leaving the body. The invisiblity cloak only has to hide the physical body to protect them form Death.
select as best answer
Dementors live off human happiness, they are such good guards of Azkaban because they can sense humans, they don't have to "see" them. Happiness to them is live bacon to men, a guy could find a plate of bacon with his eyes closed. Death wants to take the physical person(in the world of harry potter Death seems to be entirely physical), Dementors would take the soul, leaving the body. The invisiblity cloak only has to hide the physical body to protect them form Death.
posted over a year ago 
*
This is not to say Dementors cant be fooled either! They couldnt tell the difference between Barty Jr. and his Mom, or couldn't detect Sirius in his dog form!
Unspeakable posted over a year ago
ClaireVoyant said:
Dementor can sense you they don't have eyes so invisibility won't save you.
And beside dementor didn't exactly kill people, they suck your soul and leave you in vegetatife state.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LadyNottingham said:
Maybe Dumbledore was not totally honest with Harry. I mean, he probably lied or at least spun a little yarn so that Harry may not go wandering too close to Dementors even under his cloak. These creatures are the least forgiving. The old wizard was so much manipulative that I would not be surprised by this.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
sadly I agree, dumbledore had quite an impressive web of lies protecting, whats one more little white lie? lol the truth
Unspeakable posted over a year ago
*
Definitely !
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
next question »