Does anyone else think that Neville should have killed Bellatrix? if so why ?

i think that she shouldn't be killed at all
but if it is necessary for her to die then either Neville or Hermione should've killed her

I think Neville killing Bellatrix would have been justice for his parents and is a nice thought, but Neville isn't strong enough to kill her. I would have preferred it if Kingsley or some other highly skilled wizard had killed her.

I think that Neville would have killed Bellatrix well, dramatically, and would have avenged his parents. But I think that Mrs. Weasley did it better, avenging for the death of her son. The screaming was a plus.

yes,because that crazy bitch ruied his life

Yeah man! He deserved revenge, and I wouldve preferred her to be killed by Neville instead of Molly.

No,of course not!!! Coz there's no Harry Potter without Bellatrix!!!

No, Neville is too young and too innocent to kill a person. But yeah, I don't think Bellatrix should have been killed that way. A few Crucios would have served her right :P

I don't think she should have been killed at all.

no!because bellatrix is the best!

Anyone but Molly, that's just humiliating!

Nobody should've killed her honestly.

yes harry because she killed the only alive person left in harrys family but belitrix killed him.

I expected Bellatrix to die in style, I was dissapointed actually. /:

I DEFFINATLY THINK NEVIL SHOULD HAVE KILLED BELATRIX...IF NOT HIM THAN HERMIONE FOR SURE...IT JUST DIDN'T SEEM RIGHT FOR MOLLY TO KILL HER OFF

I think things worked out alright. Though he didn't kill her with his own hands - he kills Nagini and has that really triumphant moment towards the end. I think that kind of makes up for it.

Yes though nothing can beat Mrs Weasley screaming "Not My Daughter You Bitch!" at Bellatrix it would have been nice to see Neville avenging his parents.

I think that every body owe a revenge on her. so its hard to tell

No way! Nobody should kill Bellatrix, Neville especially. He's not worthy. I hate him. He's a weak, useless little nothing, a pathetic excuse for a boy. He's almost a squib. Bellatrix is amazing, honestly <3

In case you're interested, I started a fanfic where Neville actually gets to kill Bellatrix. But it's still on chapter one. I fully intend to finish it, though.

A link is here.

link

No. I think she shouldn't have killed Sirius, and instead he pounded her sorry face in.

Anyone would better than that Weasley mum coming from nowhere or no one at all. Or, maybe Voldy if he had known about her love for him. It would have been so sad. But still better.

well i guess it would make sense as she tortured his parents :D but no one should have killed her, she should still be living :'(

No he should not have. Despite everything he faced Neville was still innocent in the sense he had never killed. Molly doing it was not stupid; it showed that even though she was cast as the motherly role throughout the story she was still as strong a witch as any. She deserved her moment. Would she have been a part of The Order if she wasn't capable? It's better that Neville didn't do it. His parents wouldn't have wanted that and it would have taken away his innocence. It doesn't make him weak; he proved throughout the whole story he was not weak. People seriously need to actually read the story and try to understand the messages being conveyed before making such nonsense comments.

I did expect that to happen when I first read the series. Neville did seem to have the best claim of anyone to kill her. But in a way, I understand why it wasn't done, too. Like sylvia1103 said, making him a murderer would have ruined him. And you couldn't have another case of a rebounding spell.

That would have been justice XD