answer this question

Esme Cullen Question

why does esme have such a little part in the books and film?

 vampireluv09 posted over a year ago
next question »

Esme Cullen Answers

AliceHaleCullen said:
I'm not quite sure actually.
Carlisle is mentioned quite alot. Like in all books and films there are the bigger parts and the smaller parts.
Even though Esme's part is only small it's still an important part.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bby11us said:
I've wondered that myself. Her part was already too small in the books, and they've cut her even more in the movies. But she's important. Especially because of her suicide attempt and a certain event in NM. I can't believe that they cut out her talking to Bella about that during baseball.

I'm hoping that Stephenie has something up her sleeve and that she plans on writing a book about Carlisle and Esme. I would be eternally grateful if she did that. I don't know enough about them and their past, and their relationship. Here's hoping. =]
select as best answer
I've wondered that myself. Her part was already too small in the books, and they've cut her even more in the movies. But she's important. Especially because of her suicide attempt and a certain event in NM. I can't believe that they cut out her talking to Bella about that during baseball.

I'm hoping that Stephenie has something up her sleeve and that she plans on writing a book about Carlisle and Esme. I would be eternally grateful if she did that. I don't know enough about them and their past, and their relationship. Here's hoping. =]
posted over a year ago 
modernfan said:
the answer is simple:stephanie mayer is stupid
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
shellycane said:
It always depends on what way you look at it. Of course she doesnt get mentioned that often, but she is very important to the family. And then to Bella and even Jacob... so i guess over all her part isnt that little :D
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Jacob305 said:
because she is a mom and in most books and movies a moom is not really in it and we dont know much about her so we dont know what to do with her
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
sherrilyn said:
not too sure but she should be in the books and movies more often!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ScottishChic said:
I am so mad about that.
Esme is a fantastic character and they are all stupid for not giving her a bigger part.
I think the reason she is left out so much is because the story is not about HER! Like, The others all get a very important mention that leads to life or death situations and also, Esme has no gift so she can't give anything there.
Twilight is all about Edward/Bella and Alice.
New Moon is all about Edward/Bella/Alice and Jacob.
Eclipse is all about Edward/Bella/Jacob and Jasper and kind of Emmett because he's really into the fighting thing and Rosalie because of the story and human thing.
Breaking Dawn is all about Edward/Bella/Jacob and Renesmee so Esme has no REAL part at all, she's like just there for Carlisle.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »