This question has been asked time and time again. I like her as both because she is the same person except she is more real in New York and just a hand drawn cartoon in Andalasia. Plus she became more real-life in the end of the movie as she grew into a mature woman with a great aspect on love.

i like her as both...i wish she would keep her andalasian personality tho

I love both them.

Agree with LisaForde.

I prefer how much she grew as a person when she was in the real world