interesting question really hard to decide. Neither of them are very good fighters. Captain Hook as a pirate has some skill with the sword, though not enough to defeat a young boy like peter. He dose have his pirate's crew help, though so dose the Red Queen. She has many card at her disposal. She might just say off with his head and that would be the end of it.

I'd like to think my fave villain Captain Hook would win because he's faster and has more skill while the Queen is fat and clumsy and her obesity is her only advantage.He'd have to carve off some fat just to cut her throat.And seriously,in an actual fight,Hook would have kicked Peter Pan's little butt.

she has more minions to do her work....all Hook really had was that idiot "Smee"(think that's his name)

Seriously, The Queen Of Hearts is Pathetic in Combat, But Captain James Hook on the other hand, Or Should I say "on the other Hook" is excellent at Swordmanship skills and He'll kick the Queen Of Hearts' Butt.